• Prep Time:
  • Cooking Time:
  • Serves: 6 Servings

English Muffins, Homemade Pt 1

  • Recipe Submitted by on

Category: Yeast, Brunch, Breakfast

 Ingredients List

  • 1 ts Active dry yeast
  • 1/2 c Warm Water; (110°f)
  • 2 tb Instant mashed potatoes OR 4
  • -Tablespoons raw potato;
  • -grated
  • 1/2 c Boiling water
  • 1 c Cold Milk Plus Dripplets
  • -Water If Needed
  • 2 1/2 c All-purpose flour
  • 1 1/2 ts Salt
  • 3 tb Warn Water; (110°f)
  • 3 tb Unsalted butter


1 1/2 ts Salt dissolved in
3 tb Tepid water

EQUIPMENT: A heavy skillet or large frying pan, or a non-stick electric
skillet; muffin or crumpet rings or cat-food or tuna fish cans about
3-inches in diameter with tops and bottoms removed; a 4 to 5 tablespoon
ladle or long handled cup; spatulas both rubber and metal); and, perhaps,

PREPARATION: Dissolve yeast in 1/2 cup warm water. If using instant mashed
potatoes, soften them in 1/2 cup boiling water. If using raw grated
potatoes simmer them in 1/2 cup water until tender.

THE DOUGH: While yeast is dissolving, assemble the other ingredients. Then
into the instant or grated potatoes beat the cold milk, and stir it along
with the dissolved yeast into the flour. Beat vigorously for a minute or so
with a wooden spoon to make a smooth loose thick batter, heavier than the
usual pancake batter but not at all like the conventional dough. (Beat in
dribbles more water if batter is stiff rather then loose.) Cover with
plastic wrap and let rise, preferably at around 80°F., until batter has
risen and large bubbles have appeared in the surface (usually about 1 1/2
hoursit must be bubbly, however long it takes). Stir the batter down,
then beat in the * salt and water, beating vigorously for a minute. Cover
and let rise until bubbles again appear in the surfaceabout an hour at
80°F. The batter is now ready to become English muffins. Batter may sit for
an hour or more after its second rise, or you may use one of the delaying
tactics suggested at the end of the recipe.

PRIOR TO COOKING THE MUFFINS: When you are ready to cook the muffins, brush
insides of rings or tins fairly generously with butter; butter the surface
of griddle or frying pan lightly and set over moderate heat. When just hot
enough, so that drops of water begin to dance on it, the heat is about
right. Scoop your ladle or cup into the batter and dislodge the batter into
a ring or tin with rubber spatula; batter should be about 3/8-inch thick to
make a raised muffin twice that. (Batter should be heavy, sticky, sluggish,
but not runny, having just enough looseness to be spread out onto the
ringif you think it is too thick, beat in tepid water by dripplets.)

COOKING THE MUFFIN: The muffins are to cook slowly on one side until
bubbles, which form near the bottom of the muffin, pierce through the top
surface, and until almost the entire top changes from a wet ivory white to
a dryish gray color; this will take 6 to 8 minutes or more, depending on
the heat. (Regulate the heat so that bottoms of muffins do not color more
than a medium or pale brown.) Now the muffins are to be turned over for a
brief cooking on the other side, and at this point you can lift the rings
off them; if not turn them over and dislodge rings with the point of a
knife, cutting and poking around the edge of the rings if necessary. Cans
are sometimes more difficult to remove; you may find it useful to have a
pair of pliers for lifting, as well as a small knife for poking. Less than
a minute is usually enough for cooking the second side, which needs only a
token browning and drying out. Cool the muffins on a rack. Fresh but cold
muffins freeze beautifully and keep fresher when stored frozen, although
they will stay fresh enough wrapped airtight in a plastic bag for a day or
two in the refrigerator.

TO SERVE ENGLISH MUFFINS: The muffins must be split (not cut) in half
horizontally, since the inside texture should be slightly rough and full of
holes (the bottoms are always solid, however.) To split them, you can use a
table fork, pushing the tines into the muffin all around the circumference,
then gently tearing the two halves apart. Or use a serrated knife, cutting
a slit in one side, then tearing the muffin apart all around and inside,
using short slashes made with the point and top 1/2 inch of the knife. An
electric toaster is not at all suitable for homemade English muffins, since
the muffins are damp in texture they must be toasted very slowly under a
broiler; the slow browning dries out the interior while crusting the
surface. Toast the uncut side a minute or so, then turn and toast the cut
side for 2 to 3 minutes, until lightly browned. Butter the cut side and
return under the broiler for a moment to let the butter bubble up and sink
in. Serve as soon as possible.

DELAYING TACTICS AND SOURDOUGH: Not much can happen to ruin this dough,

continued in part 2

 Share this Recipe

Recipes by Course

Recipes by Main Ingredient

Recipes by Cuisine

Recipes by Preparation

Recipes by Occasion

Recipes by Dietary

Sign Up and Create a Cookbook Today!

Please Sign in to your Account or Sign up if you are new user.

Who loves our Healthy Recipes?